Part 24 of 70 — Original Chapter: Chapter 8: A Taste of Injustice
This article forms part of the serialised republication of Panthers, Passion & Politics – The Roger Cowan Years.
The second part of the police investigation was about the club’s purchase of 100 poker machines.
Bob Donaghy was one of the club’s two assistant managers, and his responsibilities included purchase of poker machines. Aristocrat was the largest manufacturer in the industry, but the Club had not bought any of its machines for quite a long period. Donaghy believed the quality of their machine design and security had slipped. But when the club was ready to freshen up its gaming area with 100 new machines, Donaghy recommended the latest release by Aristocrat, telling Cowan he now had confidence in their products.
They began to talk about cost. The listed price of the machines was $7,000 each. Cowan suggested that they go to Aristocrat with an offer. It was a large purchase, maybe even unprecedented in Australia. As such, it should warrant a considerable discount. They decided to offer $5,000 per machine. conditional on Aristocrat arranging the finance for leasing and subsidising the interest rate.
Aristocrat mostly agreed with the proposal but set a total price of $530,000 for the 100 machines; still an extraordinarily large discount on the $700,000 they would have paid at list price. Cowan and Donaghy were celebrating. It was a straightforward transaction, and they had done a great deal. The complications arose for Panthers in the accounting offices of Aristocrat.
Aristocrat had obtained leasing finance for the total amount of $530,000, and that was correct. But they had listed only 90 machines on their sale documents. In effect, they had financed 90 machines for $530,000 and given Panthers ten machines at no charge. It made no difference to the club, and it was Aristocrat’s own choice to account for the machines the way they did, but the ramifications moved even beyond the police investigations at Panthers in 1985, to resound in the Queensland Criminal Justice Commission in 1990.1
The purchase was the subject of almost a full hour of questioning by Mick Howe after the fraud squad officer had left having no more interest. Cowan tried in vain to explain how the price of the machines and the interest rate had been discounted. He says the long conversation seemed to travel around in circles but it can be summarised easily in just a few paragraphs:2
Mick Howe: I have been to the Liquor Administration Board to examine the records of your poker machine purchases and I found that you had applied for the purchase of 100 machines. There were 100 serial numbers listed. I then did a survey of the machines in the club and found all 100 machines with those serial numbers. However, when I looked at the finance company records I found only 90 machines listed on their records.
Cowan: I don’t know what is listed in the finance company records, but I cannot understand what the problem is. We bought 100 machines at a heavily discounted price, and we correctly submitted licence numbers to the department. You know that all the machines have been installed, and you know that Aristocrat has been paid for them. I don’t understand what you think is wrong with the transaction?
Mick Howe: You know, that’s what I have been trying to figure out, and now I can see it. If the club goes broke, the finance company will only be able to repossess 90 machines, yet they have financed the payment for 100.
Reflecting on this exchange Cowan commented,
I was astounded at the detective’s logic: “Well so what!” I said. “We would hardly buy 100 machines if we thought we were likely to be going broke. In any event, if we had paid the list price for the machines, the borrowings would have been a lot more and the finance company’s security a lot less.”
Mick Howe remained unconvinced. He just did not get it.
The third matter for police investigation was the sale of the Station Street property. Rumours of something questionable in that transaction were investigated. Most of the police and government officers involved in the police raids on Panthers walked away satisfied that Cowan and the Club had nothing to answer on the original allegations.
Mick Howe stood out as the expectation.
The Station Street property transactions, discussed earlier in this series as part of the Club’s property strategy3, were also examined. Again, investigators found no evidence of criminal wrongdoing.
By now, most of the allegations that had prompted the raids had failed to produce the evidence investigators had hoped to find. For many involved, the matter appeared to be drawing to a close. Detective Sergeant Mick Howe saw things differently.
To receive new Parts and occasional project updates by email, you may subscribe below.
Readers who hold recollections, documents, or material relevant to this history are welcome to contribute via the Commentary & Contributions page.
Project Updates
Receive updates when new parts are published.
- Read Beyond the Book — Queensland Criminal Justice Commission for more on this. ↩︎
- The following paragraphs are not a verbatim conversation but a paraphrasing of the conversation that eliminates the repetition and redundancy that characterises these types of discussion. ↩︎
- See Part 13 — Bulding the Future, a Block at a Time ↩︎
Panthers, Passion & Politics - The Roger Cowan Years 