Originally Chapter 22 of Panthers, Passion & Politics, Royal Commission Powers examines the extraordinary investigative powers available to the Temby Inquiry and their consequences for Roger Cowan.
The chapter combines Jennie Bentley’s criticism of the inquiry process with Roger’s personal recollections of what he described as the worst period of his life. His account reveals the uncertainty, psychological strain and sense of injustice he experienced during the proceedings, together with the effects of the accompanying media coverage.
In preparing the serialised edition, this chapter was removed from the main narrative because much of its discussion of the inquiry’s powers and justification overlaps with material examined elsewhere. Roger’s personal account, however, provides a perspective not conveyed as directly in the surrounding chapters.
It is reproduced here as part of the original publication, preserving both the author’s interpretation of events and Roger’s recollections of his experience. Readers should distinguish those perspectives from the formal findings of the Temby Inquiry, which are addressed elsewhere in the series.
Royal Commission Powers
Royal Commissions exercise investigative powers that go well beyond those available in ordinary legal proceedings. They can compel witnesses to give evidence and produce documents, subject to the protections and limitations established by law. Refusal to comply with lawful requirements can attract serious penalties, including imprisonment.
Such powers are generally reserved for investigations considered sufficiently serious or difficult that ordinary investigative procedures may be inadequate. Examples include the NSW Police Royal Commission and the NSW Royal Commission into Drug Trafficking.
Section 41X of the NSW Registered Clubs Act 1976 allowed an inquiry to exercise powers conferred under the Royal Commissions Act 1923. The Department of Gaming and Racing could initiate such an inquiry on the basis of allegations of corrupt or improper conduct, without first establishing that those allegations were supported by evidence.1
The identity of those making the allegations, and the material supporting them, need not necessarily be disclosed to the subjects of the inquiry. This created the possibility of an investigation being established on allegations that had not been adequately tested.
An inquiry can be called just in the hope something will turn up.
Our political system is celebrated for its constitutional safeguards. But any majority government can give itself these powers, and use them to silence dissent, weaken opponents, and punish subjects who have made its task of ruling difficult.
A person charged with murder, rape, drug-peddling or other serious crimes is protected by a set of legal rights developed over hundreds of years.
- The suspect is investigated by officers of the law until there is sufficient evidence for charges to be laid.
- The suspect must be fully informed of any charges and of their rights to silence and legal representation.
- At the hearing to establish guilt or innocence, the suspect has the choice to give evidence or not give evidence.
- Rules of evidence generally exclude irrelevant material and restrict the circumstances in which a previous criminal record may be admitted.
- The suspect is presumed innocent until the prosecutors can convince the judge or jury of guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
- Court rules lay down standards regulating what forms of questioning are permissible.
- Hearsay evidence is generally excluded, subject to recognised exceptions.
- A lot of court time is taken up with debate about what evidence is admissible.
In an inquiry exercising Royal Commission powers, many of these protections do not apply in the same way. In the government’s case against Panthers and Cowan:
- The allegations leading to this Inquiry had been investigated by officers of the government over nearly a year. Nothing was found to justify any charges or complaints against the Club or any individual in the Club.
- Cowan and the Club were compelled to deliver information on short notice and in broad categories. For example, Cowan was told to deliver all his financial records for ten years, including those of his wife and family company.
- There was no charge to answer or defend, only allegations.
- There was no right not to give evidence or refuse to answer questions not related to the allegations.
- There were limited opportunities to object to questioning. Throughout the hearing, Cowan’s lawyer made no objection to a question.
- There were no boundaries for questioning. Any answer could become the track for an entirely different line of questioning.
- There was no warning of the line of questioning to be followed.
- Hearsay was admitted.
How does such an inquiry affect the individual? Cowan has described it as the worst time in his life. Even reliving the events two years on is traumatic.
When the inquiry was over I had a cup of coffee with Terrence Lynch. Terrence strongly advised me to take at least four months off work and do nothing unless it was relaxing, and of personal interest. He said I would probably be underestimating the impact the inquiry would have on me, and it would be better to take preventative measures rather than letting it build up. He was right of course.
Unfortunately, I did not take his advice.
A few weeks before the inquiry started, I attended a function where I spent some time with some solicitor friends. They were aghast when I told them I did not intend to be legally represented. “I’ll just tell the truth,” I told them. “I have nothing to hide, so why go to the expense.” How naïve that was, and they told me so in no uncertain terms.
I should have taken their advice immediately.
Leading up to the inquiry I underestimated its seriousness. During the inquiry I underestimated what was happening behind the scenes. After the inquiry I underestimated the severity of the psychological impact it would have.
In other words, I never really came to grips with it at all.
It was made worse by my perception that the premier and treasurer of NSW wanted to do as much damage as possible to my reputation and credibility. To make matters worse, it seemed to me that they had a powerful ally in The Sydney Morning Herald.
Such powerful adversaries are enough to make anyone nervous.
I knew that the group of people who had been attacking me publicly was behind the allegations that brought about the investigation, but no way of knowing the nature of the accusations. I was also having difficulty coming to grips with the fact that people would act that way.
The government announcement of the inquiry was worded to make me look bad and yet I had not been charged with any offence. I did not have access to the allegations, and I had not had the opportunity to answer them. There is nothing more damaging to peace of mind than injustice.
It was explained to me that the appointment of Ian Temby was an indication that the government was very serious. When the full implications of the Royal Commission rules were explained to me, it added to a very menacing environment. For that period, and it felt like a very long period indeed, I lived in a state of pure stress. I started out by telling myself that all I had to do was answer their questions truthfully and there was nothing they could do to hurt me. Soon, I discovered I was wrong. A throw-away line from Ian Temby in the first few days — that perhaps there could be $800,000 missing — appeared as a headline the next day in the Herald, making it sound like a fact.2 There had been no evidence to support the comment, and I had given evidence that there was nothing missing. I started to realise that they were going to extract every possible headline regardless of the evidence or the truth.
I would toss and turn at night with the same questions flying around my head.
What if I have made a mistake somewhere?
What if something has happened that could make me look guilty and I don’t even know about it?
What have they been told that could possibly justify this time and expense?
What if I have been set up somewhere and not realised it?
They seem determined to make me look bad, and what lengths will they go to?
The questions and various imagined outcomes produced a burning sensation in my gut. I would wake up tired, but determinedly telling myself that I must be strong.
At times I could feel myself losing hope. The enemy seemed too powerful. Was I becoming neurotic? There seemed to be no relief from despair and hopelessness. But it was vital to hide those feelings. It was not the time to show any weakness, no matter how I felt.
There was no privacy and there I was in the full glare of the spotlight — the last place I would normally choose. Sometimes when I walked towards the entrance to the court, there were more television crews than normal. I would wonder what they had been told to expect that day. They knew more than I did.
Every morning Phyllis and I would wake up fearful of what had been published overnight in the Herald. Our hearts would sink as we read another headline that made me look like a criminal. When there was no story, we would breathe a sigh of relief, but the peace was always short lived.
Both the Herald and the Western Weekender gave me the impression from the outset that they intended to brand me as corrupt and dishonest. Fortunately, Alan Jones at 2GB seemed to wake up to what was going on very early, and his comments helped me keep some balance. He proved that if anyone was prepared to look carefully and logically at what was happening, they would be able to see what a farce it really was. It provided a spark of hope that in the end some sanity might prevail and the truth would win.
Despite the often-repeated claim that “you can’t believe everything you read”, people do believe what they read.
In a media dominated world, our opinions, knowledge and attitudes are very strongly influenced by what is communicated to us by the media. Those who experience the dishonesty of the media first hand become more cynical, and nobody could be more cynical than me.
The positive findings of the inquiry could never undo those negative stories and headlines. Even after the report was handed down, the government continued to attack my credibility.
If anything positive came out of it, it was a deeper understanding of how seemingly unrelated events interconnect, and the realisation that I had failed to handle some quite difficult situations as well as I should have.
It reinforced in my mind the difficulty of bridging differences in values. Let’s use a topical example. A Christian, a Muslim and an atheist see certain things very differently. They could probably work together very well, but not if religion was the agenda. In many ways business is similar. If you don’t recognise and respect those differences, you can easily find yourself caught up in misunderstandings and conflict without knowing why.
Even this matter of losing a fight and then going to authorities to “tell tales” about your opponent is outside my understanding. If you don’t recognise and respect those differences, you can easily find yourself caught up in misunderstandings and conflict without knowing why. You just get up and try again. I tried to teach that value to my four sons and I observed it when I was a teacher — “don’t tell tales, stand up for yourself.”
I have difficulty reconciling in my mind the picture of children running off telling tales to their teacher or mother with that of a tough ex-front rower and a burly ex-policeman running to the authorities with complaints that had no factual basis. It doesn’t fit unless they really believed they were reporting criminal activities, but what was their evidence?
Related Topics
- Part 69 — The Temby Inquiry Begins: Panthers in the Firing Line
- Part 73 — The Temby Inquiry: The Findings and the Fallout
- Part 74 — A Royal Commission into Corruption at Panthers
- Beyond the Book: The Temby Inquiry
- Beyond the Book: The Temby Inquiry — Instrument of Appointment (30 April 2004)
Related Themes
Conflict · Temby Inquiry · Governance
To receive new Parts and occasional project updates by email, you may subscribe below.
Readers who hold recollections, documents, or material relevant to this history are welcome to contribute via the Commentary & Contributions page.
Project Updates
Receive updates when new parts are published.
- Editorial note: The Temby Inquiry was established under section 41X of the Registered Clubs Act 1976 and exercised specified powers under the Royal Commissions Act 1923. It was an investigative inquiry, not a criminal trial. Consequently, the rules governing compulsory testimony, evidence and questioning differed from those applying in criminal proceedings. The exercise of these powers remained subject to statutory requirements and judicial supervision.
↩︎ - Contemporary reporting confirms that the question of approximately $800,000 in payments through Phyro Holdings attracted considerable attention during the Temby Inquiry. On 23 June 2004, The Sydney Morning Herald reported that an estimated $800,000 appeared not to have been accounted for after employment and other costs were deducted from payments made to Phyro. Roger Cowan disputed this, insisting that he could account for every cent. On 30 July 2004, the Western Weekender published a prominent headline, “$800,000 unaccounted”. The particular Herald headline recalled by Cowan has not yet been located.
↩︎